Monday, January 12, 2015

No more happily ever afters

I have a question today. But before that listen to this story that I shared with the children of The Book Club this Sunday. I'll keep it short I promise.


The story (The Book Keeper)


... is set in the year 2042. It talks of a scenario where books and writing are extinct. ibooks, laptops, computers, tablets and phones are everywhere. However, there is this one poor Bangladeshi boy, Santanu, who possesses a book (A Bengali adaptation of Matilda). He doesn't understand the Bengali script so he uses it as a diary, address book, notepad and a scribble pad all in one.

One day the Internet crashes. The parents are angry and the children, restless. They are forced to play outdoors and stumble upon a dilapidated building which happens to be a deserted library. They start to love the place. They read, run around and learn to make up stories. Then one day the Internet comes back and the kids all disappear again back to their electronic world leaving Santanu alone but happy with the books. You can read the full story here. (While you're there you might like to check out the site. It has some amazing stories from around the world).


The question

So tell me now, does the ending bother you? It did bother me. Would you have thought of altering it before you shared the story with the kids?

I was sorely tempted to do that. I've tampered with stories earlier, mostly the so called 'fairytales', when the kids were younger. I did away with the gory and the unpleasant, evening out the rough patches making it perfect as it could get.

This time however I let it be. For one, this ending might be more near the truth than the one I have in mind, two - changing it would amount to trolling someone else's story, three - maybe it's time to let the kids figure out the situation for themselves. I sure was curious to see their reaction - would they accept it like it's inevitable or 'normal' (Yikes!!) or would they feel saddened like I was?


What the kids had to say

The kids completely loved it - the whole story. There were exclamations of 'cool' and 'awesome' at the idea of all kids having phones and tabs. But there also were 'haws' at the idea of no books. They accepted the story in a way more positive manner than what I'd ever imagined. Rather than a black and white approach they found many angles to it. Most said they liked the ending for Santanu's sake. They liked that Santanu could enjoy being by himself with just books for company. Some said this wasn't 'the end' at all and that finally the kids got bored of their computers after getting a taste of the good stuff and came back.

It's such joy to watch children think and talk and discuss. Yet one more time I was made to realise how I underestimate the way they think.

25 comments:

  1. Kids have such different and positive perspective. I can't imagine a world without books. It would be

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Charmless ...
      Blame my phone, entered too quickly:)

      Delete
    2. Ha ha.. My phone does that too, it simply decides I've said enough! You're right - kids do offer fresh perspectives.

      Delete
  2. I loved ther story because it talks about reality without sugar coating it. I think we need more stories like that one, to be honest. Oh, I don't mean we take away happy endings, but every now and then kids also need to hear these stories, the ones they can relate to and then make informed decisions about the same. I am glad you did not 'tamper' with the end, Tulika. But then again, I know you wouldn't :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh you don't know how close I was to changing it. I do abhor unhappy endings. But then you always overestimate the goodness in people Shailaja.

      Delete
  3. I can't imagine a world without books...I think you are doing a great thing with the kids here... Giving them the gift of reading , the love of reading!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, me too. Thanks for that generous compliment.

      Delete
  4. I'm torn between letting children know the truth while keeping the dreams alive for them. Sometimes though, I think we forget how resilient children can be. Sure, we need to read age-appropriate things to them; yet, we can educate and discuss things further. A lady at my book club read Harry Potter with her 6 year old son. He is intellectually gifted and enjoyed the books but at the same time was disturbed in book 4 when Voldemort kills Cedric for no reason. It required a lot of discussion and explanation of good versus evil and the like.

    This website sounds good...thanks for sharing! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My point exactly Sanch. The greys are difficult to explain.

      Delete
  5. Definitely food for thought! And I love your book club and the work you put into it!!
    Yes, I did worry about this too when the kids were younger but then I remembered that I had read through similar stuff and survived :).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We did. However, different times and perhaps a greater awareness of what our kids are learning might make us want to act differently.

      Delete
  6. I loved the story. And the ending, well, I definitely loved what the children took out of it. We do tend to underestimate them, don't we? The story also made me feel a little guilty as we've gone the electronic way so much, just because its more convenient.

    I love your book club posts. I love the way you handle them! I wish I had the patience to do something like this. And also wish that daughter of mine still liked to listen to stories she's just too impatient to hear someone read to her

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Smitha. We have a problem that's quite the reverse. H and N like to listen to stories so much that they won't read!!! Oh and that compliment on how I handle them is not really justified. You should see the chaos at the meetings! The only heartening thing is that they keep coming back so I guess they musn't be disliking the club!

      Delete
  7. Kids are very intelligent and i think sometimes we the adults need to sit and LEARN from them

    Bikram's

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am thrilled that my grandson loves books and I can't imagine a world without them as much as it seems to be leaning in that direction. 2042 or sooner. What a great idea to share with the children

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ... and I'm envious since my kids just aren't taking to it. Yeah me too - no books would be weird.

      Delete
  9. Interesting questions there. I wouldn't mess with anyone else's story, but I am glad that the children were exposed to and enjoyed the real books. It will be a sad day in this world when they disappear for good! Hopefully, not in my lifetime.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mine too Debbie and I hope not in my children's too. There is something so comforting about book, they need to be around for a long long time.

      Delete
  10. for the ending, i feel kinda sad. Now more and more are moving to e-books. pretty soon the hardcopy of books will not be appreciated.

    For me, I love both type of books

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks for visiting Small Kucing. I love both kinds of books too but I cannot do without the good solid ones.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The story is indeed disturbing... Why go to 2042? Now only children and WE are so like that...
    It will be curse to live without books... not playing and meeting up with family and friends in person..
    Thanks for sharing

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, it would sad indeed. I do hope that day never comes.

      Delete
  13. Good call. When it comes to literature, I obsess about whether they are ready for a particular book or not, but once I give it to them, it is theirs to read and internalise as they see fit.

    ReplyDelete

Glad to have you here. It's your turn to share your thoughts...

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails